One of my sisters recently asked me if I had forgiven our mom. I thought she was referring to something that happened many years before, but today I realized she may have been talking about an event a few years ago. That event left me betrayed, hurt, and angry for a long time. But have I forgiven mom? What exactly does that mean?

Some say you should forgive and forget. When I hear that I always wonder how they expect a person to purposely forget something. It’s not like your brain is a dry-erase board. I assume what they really mean is ‘forgive and let go’. Which, of course, can be pretty darn hard to do.

When I hear people say they’ve forgiven someone, many times I hear an element of pride, or ego, in their voices. As if saying that means they are superior to the one they forgive. That makes the cynical part of me wonder if they forgave because they were ready to let go, or if they forgave to show themselves a better person. Which is different from forgiving to make themselves a better person.

I think ego is perceived in forgiveness when a person feels the need to tell the other one that the’ve been forgiven. If you are truly letting go, does the other person need to know? Are you forgiving for your peace of mind, or to be able to face the other one and say, ‘I’m better than you’?
Is there a little bit of smug humility in there?

Someone once told me that they had finally reached a point where they could forgive me. To this day, I have no idea what I did that I had to be forgiven for, and it hurts to think I did something that impacted them. But I’m glad they were able to let go.
Of course there are always situations where a person needs to face the other one, needs to look them in the eye and speak the final line of their story. To be able to be strong, say they are letting go, and then walk away. That’s strength, not ego.

I do’t think the act of forgiving ever means that a person is saying what happened was okay. Forgiving never means, to me anyway, that what happened should have happened. This is where I start getting hung up on forgiveness. Because isn’t that what forgiveness is saying? I’m letting go of that. I didn’t like it, but it’s okay, we’ll just move on. Why should someone be allowed to go on like nothing happened?

That makes me think that forgiving someone means they don’t get ‘punished’ for what they did. There are no visible consequences.
Yet, who are we to be the judge and jury? How do we know they return to their life unaffected? Even though we may forgive someone, that doesn’t mean we were right, or blameless, either. No argument happens in a vacuum.

I don’t claim any clarity of understanding or wisdom. I’m going to be honest here and it won’t reflect well on me. When I’m asked if I’m going to forgive someone, I get a bit testy. Of course I’m not. I’m going to walk away. I’m going to work on letting go of my anger or hurt. But I’m going to sit back and wait for Karma. This doesn’t mean I brood on things. After all, when my sister asked me if I’d forgiven mom, I’d clearly forgotten the Big Event.

I can walk away. I can choose whether to have that person in my life or not. I can protect my peace of mind. I can have very clear boundaries to make sure something like that never happens again. I can build a very high, strong wall that the other person can’t get through. If that means I’ve forgiven someone, then I guess I have.


No I do not forgive my or sister, but I did just walk away.
Rochelle
LikeLike
Thought provoking post. I believe I am in your camp on this forgiveness thing. To me, it’s like saying, “It’s okay that you hurt me.” Well, it really isn’t okay. Not if I can’t brush it off, or take responsibility for my role in whatever it was that caused me to be hurt (yes, sometimes there is no shared responsibility). There is some pain you carry your entire life. If you’re lucky, you come to terms with it, and it doesn’t rule you. You use it to inform or shape your approach to life going forward, hopefully in a positive or at least a peaceful way. I hesitate to use the word “stronger” to describe the emergence from pain — it’s so … so … trite, dismissive, so designed to make other people feel better — don’t you think?
LikeLike
This really makes me think. Here’s what I think: we can’t forget, and it’s hard to forgive when someone has caused us a grievous wound. But what I do is to sort of give them minus points while conceding that they did what they did because something hurt them first. Then I carry on as before, but they are lowered in my esteem unless they redeem it with an explanation or apology. The inner process is not so clear, of course, but this is the best way I can explain it.
LikeLike
Forgiveness is complex, no argument there. I think I prefer to let things go. In forgiveness there is an implication of one who harmed another and the one who was harmed. Often harms are not intended, and a simple ‘I’m so sorry’ when the unintended hurt is realized is sufficient. Or if I realize a hurt was not intentional I do my best to let go of my attachment to feeling it.
But when the harm is intentional or repeated then the one experiencing it has to make decisions: do I become compassionate to the perpetrator, holding space for their human imperfections or do I protect myself? Sometimes I trial compassion but if I end up stretching myslf more and more then i do my best to let this person go. This scenario is a rarity but happens now and then.
I do my best to encompass the idea that most people are probably not intending to hurt me. I assume positive intentions, as the saying goes.
LikeLike
I think I understand it until I start being honest with myself and then I see so many different shades of forgiveness, and so many different emotions that it ties into. You bring up a huge consideration – it the hurt was intentional or not, and if the behavior is repeated. I think it’s important to cling to the thought that the majority of people, even in this day and age, do not intend to consciously hurt another person. Maybe that’s being ‘Pollyanna’ but I prefer to hope in that rather than believe in the alternative.
LikeLike